Login Required

This content is restricted to University of Auckland staff and students. Log in with your username to view.

Log in

More about logging in

Vicky Ward profiles the life of media mogul Robert Maxwell, whose story helps pull back the veil on his daughter Ghislaine's mysterious past. (Part 1 of 3)

An investigative documentary series focusing on the role Ghislaine Maxwell allegedly played as an accomplice to Jeffrey Epstein.

Primary Title
  • Chasing Ghislaine
Episode Title
  • Sins of the Father
Date Broadcast
  • Wednesday 1 December 2021
Start Time
  • 21 : 45
Finish Time
  • 22 : 55
Duration
  • 70:00
Episode
  • 1
Channel
  • Three
Broadcaster
  • MediaWorks Television
Programme Description
  • An investigative documentary series focusing on the role Ghislaine Maxwell allegedly played as an accomplice to Jeffrey Epstein.
Episode Description
  • Vicky Ward profiles the life of media mogul Robert Maxwell, whose story helps pull back the veil on his daughter Ghislaine's mysterious past. (Part 1 of 3)
Classification
  • M
Owning Collection
  • Chapman Archive
Broadcast Platform
  • Television
Languages
  • English
Captioning Languages
  • English
Captions
Live Broadcast
  • No
Rights Statement
  • Made for the University of Auckland's educational use as permitted by the Screenrights Licensing Agreement.
Subjects
  • Documentary television programs--United States
  • Maxwell, Ghislaine, 1961--
  • Epstein, Jeffrey, 1953-2019
  • Child trafficking
  • Child sex offenders
Genres
  • Crime
  • Documentary
Hosts
  • Vicky Ward (Presenter)
Ghislaine Maxwell is facing new charges. - Ghislaine Maxwell is accused of finding and grooming underage girls to be sexually abused by her ex-boyfriend, Jeffrey Epstein. - This is on top of six charges Maxwell was already facing tied to Epstein's alleged sex trafficking network. - 'Ghislaine Maxwell, the British socialite 'and one-time lover of disgraced child abuser Jeffrey Epstein, 'is behind bars, facing trial. 'The charges against her? 'Finding and grooming young girls for Epstein. 'According to indictments, she was allegedly a central figure in his massive sex trafficking operation. 'The government has laid out the cases of four underage girls the duo is accused of trafficking 'over a period spanning more than a decade.' - NEWSREADER: Prosecutors say not only did Maxwell recruit young girls for Epstein, but she actually took part in sexually abusing the teens. - 'If you find the idea of a privileged, educated woman 'doing something like this to other women completely shocking,' you're not alone. Many of Ghislaine's British friends have told me privately that they are stunned. Where had the clever, glittering, Oxford-educated woman they'd known gone? My name is Vicky Ward. - Vicky Ward, everybody. - I'm a journalist in New York, and I've known Ghislaine casually for many years. In a strange twist of fate, I was also one of the first reporters to investigate Jeffrey Epstein ` that was back in 2002. I spoke to him then for hours, and I've kept the transcripts of those conversations ` one of the very few interviews that has ever been done with him. - Any girl stuff that you haven't told me about? It seems somewhat strange that an article about me has no girls in it. - I was also the first journalist who was trusted by two of Jeffrey's survivors with on-the-record sexual abuse allegations, and that would make me an inadvertent part of the story. I now understand that the root of Jeffrey's ability to cover up his crimes was his extraordinary skill at manipulation, as well as the very powerful figures who surrounded him. When I re-read the transcripts of our conversations, I saw that Jeffrey had left me breadcrumbs. The key to understanding Epstein and the power structures that protected him had been staring me in the face this entire time. With Jeffrey Epstein's death, Ghislaine Maxwell may be the last person who knows the secrets of his criminal enterprise. - JEFFREY: You know, she's my best friend. She has been for a very long time. (PENSIVE, INTRIGUING MUSIC) Captions by Jade Fernandes. Captions were made with the support of NZ On Air. www.able.co.nz Copyright Able 2021 (CAR HORN TOOTS) - The mysterious death of Jeffrey Epstein in a jail cell in the summer of 2019 has left Ghislaine Maxwell standing almost literally in his shoes. She's the one now in jail, facing charges so serious that it's possible she'll be in prison for the rest of her life. She denies it all. Ghislaine has been denied bail repeatedly. Her older brother, Ian, went on television to plead for her release. - She's lost 20 pounds. She's losing her hair. She can't concentrate. She has a flashlight shone in her cell every 15 minutes during the night, so she has no sleep of any real quality. And that is torture. - It seems that the government wants to find out what Ghislaine knows about Jeffrey Epstein's operations. Well, so do I. I've been trying to unravel this mystery for almost 20 years, and when she was arrested, I decided to try again for a podcast and now for this documentary. Of course, with COVID-19, I haven't been able to travel to interview anyone, so I've had to do it by Zoom, or in a socially-distanced office setting. Keep in mind that even though Ghislaine is the focal point, and is certainly responsible for her own actions, this, at its core, is a story about the power of men. As I've come to realise, all the sticky threads of this story merge together to create a giant web ` a web that is still intact, even after Jeffrey's death. Now Ghislaine, under pressure, threatens to expose it. While you may think you know the story of Jeffrey Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell is the gatekeeper to a tale that's even deeper and darker. And I've come to realise that if you want to understand Ghislaine, you have to start with her father, Robert Maxwell. - ARCHIVE: Mr Maxwell, you're frequently described in the press as 'irrepressible'. Are you feeling perhaps a little more repressible tonight? - Well, I don't know what being irrepressible or repressible means. I get on with the job in hand. I am a doer. I never give up. - Robert Maxwell was tall, dark and charismatic. In middle age, he became vastly overweight, but this didn't dampen his magnetism. Women, moguls, and obviously his family craved his attention. He was an extraordinary man who rose from being a poor Czechoslovakian immigrant to a globally-famous media mogul. - He came from a very poor family` Jewish family in Czechoslovakia. Hoch ` that was his surname. Escaped before most of his family died in the Holocaust. He then got to Britain. He got a military cross for storming a German machine post. He was part of the rebuilding of western Germany, and began various publishing and print companies. - He started off by buying a small publishing outfit called Pergamon Press, which published scientific journals. Those were important, because they were useful information for various national leaders. - And no one has any doubt that Pergamon is a sound business. - But Maxwell was a man of huge hunger and appetite, and I think once he saw what Pergamon could do for him in terms of influence around the world, he realised that the next step was to try to own newspapers. - He appears to have decided to get into a battle with Rupert Murdoch, who is the other great press baron in this country, partly through the Daily Mirror, which he bought along with various other acquisitions. And it was when he had the means to publicise himself, the country became aware of him as this larger-than-life figure. - He was hugely famous in England. I mean, he and Rupert Murdoch were figures who loomed really large in the public consciousness. - You understand that you're a very controversial man in this country. - I'm delighted. - He was a global colossus. He was a man who had huge media interest, but also huge political relationships with the president of America, Israel, Germany, Russia, Britain, France, and everything. - Biographer Tom Bower knew him and his family. - They say about Robert Maxwell, he treated his servants as directors, and his directors as servants. - (WHISTLES) - 'He was ruthless in his relationships...' - (BLEEP) off. - '...with the people who might have helped him.' But, at the same time, knew as well how to seduce them ` with caviar and Krug champagne. - One of his constant phrases to the minions was, 'Who pays your wages, mister?' There were occasions when I was on the receiving end of that, and, (SIGHS) OK, it was my turn this morning. (STAMMERS) This afternoon, let's hope it's somebody else's turn. - What do you think of this meeting? - Think it's excellent. - Good that it hasn't started yet. You wait and see. (MEN LAUGH) - Writer Nicholas Stafford-Deitsch went to school with Maxwell's youngest son, Kevin. - I had a girlfriend at the time, and we ran into Kevin somewhere, and he kindly invited us up to swim. And we arrived, and as we got down to the pool area, Robert Maxwell was lying sunbathing, which was quite a substantial sight. And he said, 'Who the hell are you?' And I explained that Kevin had invited us to swim. And my girlfriend, she was very nervous, and she pulled a packet of cigarettes out of her pocket, and lit a cigarette. And he turned on her very viciously, and he sort of said, 'What the hell do you think you're doing? Don't you realise how stupid you are smoking?' And I think he reduced her to tears. And I at the time was big and brave, so I said, 'You don't talk to my girlfriend like that.' And his whole demeanour changed, and he started smirking as if he thought, 'This is rather funny,' and then became quite charming. And he said, 'Oh yes, Kevin did mention you'd be along soon. Yes, enjoy your swim.' He was a bully, and someone who backed down if you stood up to him. But I think he was doing it for his own amusement. - His wife told me that he had a chip on his shoulder because of his background. He would have been considered too flamboyant, too rich, and there is a little undercurrent of anti-Semitism in Britain ` certainly against a successful Jew who'd come from nothing. - Maxwell's bullying was not confined to outsiders. He ruled his family with an iron fist as well. He and his wife, Betty, had nine children. Ghislaine was the youngest. - She told me that she had always set herself goals. Her first job was for her father at 12 years old. He was interested in computers very early on, and she was learning how to programme on a Wang computer. (INTRIGUING MUSIC) - She and two of her brothers, Kevin and Ian, all went to Marlborough College in Wiltshire, and then they went to Oxford. Ghislaine went to Balliol College in Oxford, which is one of the hardest colleges to get into. - Betty said that although Robert had had a chip, she felt that he had given the children security, and that they didn't have this feeling of inferiority. I don't know if that was wishful thinking. He certainly gave them plenty of other complexes, I think. - And what was her relationship with her mother like? - I think Betty was a very cold, austere woman who had collaborated with Robert Maxwell's brutality towards his children; never protested. The thing about the Maxwell children from what I could see ` there's no weakness. They're never weak. They proved themselves by being stubbornly strong. That is their survival gene. And they were very disciplined. They had to work hard. - At one point, Maxwell even fired his son Ian. - I taught them as youngsters, whenever you have to choose between duty and love... you must opt for duty. He chose love; he had to pay the penalty. - The guy, in many ways, was a monster. - Yeah. - He treated as children the way he treated the people that worked for him. The people who worked for him, he taped them; he had kept files on them. He treated people appallingly. - Martin Dillon, co-author of another book on Maxwell, says the one person who escaped some of this treatment was Ghislaine. - Ghislaine was his darling. She was youngest daughter, she was pretty, and she was very bright, well-educated, was also a linguist to some extent. And he really had her around his life more than any of his other children. And you can see the photographs of where she's at a football match with him, and it's quite apparent that he really loves this young girl. And he names his yacht the 'Lady Ghislaine'. He was warm with her. He was... You know, he was very thoughtful, caring, and he was wanting to give her what she wanted. - She did have charm. That's why her father liked her so much ` because she did have the charm of the young` the youngest daughter. They knew how to twirl him around her finger as well, to an extent. And he was very vulnerable to that. So she did learn how to manipulate him, to an extent. She knew what he wanted, and gave him what he wanted, which is ludicrous obedience. - There is one scene in the book where you describe this grovelling letter that she had to write to her father, because she'd gone to this dinner where he was getting an award, and felt she hadn't given him a proper description. I mean, that to me, was amazing. - This is the force of Robert Maxwell's personality. Not only his children, but also politicians, and bankers, and the rest, also bow to his astonishing personality. - Ghislaine's friends from Oxford don't want to speak on the record, but they have very clear memories of the Maxwell family home ` Headington Hill Hall. She would often invite her university friends to come home for the weekend, and they began to dread that invitation. And the reason for this was her father. She would say, you know, 'Daddy, Daddy, I want to introduce my friends to you.' And he would say, you know, 'I'm not interested in meeting your friends. 'I just want to go have something to eat.' And one friend remembered how Ghislaine was playing chess... and Robert Maxwell walked up and just moved Ghislaine's chess piece without saying a word, without asking her, and then he just walked away. And the person I know who witnessed this, was completely horrified and said it was such a sort of aggressive power play. It was quite deliberate. He knew exactly what he was doing, and Ghislaine didn't say anything. (TENSE, PENSIVE MUSIC) - I met Ghislaine fairly soon after I went back to do my masters, so she was doing her bachelors. It was just some social event in which the conversation suddenly changed direction rather dramatically. Ghislaine just sort of looked me in the eye and said, 'Will you take me out to dinner?' I remember being rather impressed and thinking Ghislaine was quite sophisticated. I thought, 'Why not?' Quite soon after sitting down, Ghislaine made a remark to the effect that she was so proud of who her father was, that she could always find a story about him in the newspaper, and on a good day, she could find two stories. She spoke a great deal about her father. I mean, I don't remember very much else about the conversation. I think that there was a great deal of self-confidence on the surface, but I'm not sure deeper down. I think her character was very dependent upon who her father was. - There was something flawed within that particular personality, which is Ghislaine Maxwell, and I think a lot of it comes out of that relationship she had with both her mother and her father ` particularly with her father. I mean, she adored him. And she must have known that he was, you know, a really disgusting man in many respects. But I think a lot of girls, you know, love their fathers, even though their fathers are villains. And he was a villain. to celebrate his 65th birthday party. (INDISTINCT CHATTER) - According to all the biographies of Robert Maxwell, the irony of all the glitz and the trappings, you know ` the yachts, and the planes, and the helicopter, was that it was all based on a sham. He kept this media empire afloat by constantly moving funds around to appear as if he was much richer than he really was. - The whole nature of Robert Maxwell's operation was to steal money, because he didn't have any. He was` He was bankrupt. Throughout his whole life, he was condemned as a crook in one instance after another. Whether it was in 1954 in London with a publishing scam; in 1969 ` that was another fraud he got away with. He always got away. He always talked his way out, and bamboozled and bulldozed the opposition and the authorities aside because he was so courageous, purposeful, ruthless, a gambler, and all the rest of it. - Are you saying there's a witch hunt on against you? - Well, I certainly would say that the city establishment have` are running a witch hunt against me. - The publishing business he built served a second purpose ` access. Including to places most people never travelled. - He was using a publishing empire to get an audience in, you know, parts of the Soviet Union. And he was going to leaders of countries, like in Bulgaria, to Todor Zhivkov, the dead spot there, and saying, 'You know I would love to have your autobiography published, 'because people should really know about you.' - He had a long-standing relationship with Mikhail Gorbachev, dating back to the years after World War II. - The relationship between Maxwell and Gorbachev was close. There's no doubt he was very, very involved and instrumental in helping Russian Jews come to Israel. - Maxwell did some very bad stuff; he also did some very good stuff. I mean, Maxwell got thousands upon thousands of Jews out of the Soviet Union. Maxwell did a lot of business with the KGB. He did a lot of business with organised crime syndicates. He also did business with police intelligence, though he didn't agree to work for them full-time. - Martin Dillon believes Maxwell operated for a third intelligence agency as well. - He did a lot of business with Mossad ` particularly beginning in the early 1980s until his death in 1991. - Maxwell denied that while he was alive. But three additional sources tell me he was involved with Israeli intelligence in the 1980s, including former Mossad officer Victor Ostrovsky. - Basically, he was gathering information, making contacts, making connections using his power base, to change leaders' minds, give access to people from the agency to other people. - When you say the agency, you mean the` the Mossad? The Mossad? - Yes. - So he was` he was a Mossad agent? Robert Maxwell was? - I don't think you would ever consider himself an agent. I don't think he ever thought that he's spying for Israel. He wasn't. What he was doing is gathering information by being who he was and then giving access ` making a lot of money on the side doing that. He also had a lot of financial help in the beginning from the Shamir group, in order to develop his businesses. So he would get it as a loan, and then would come the pressure. - You mean the Prime Minister of Israel, Shamir? - Yes. - Would loan him money? Would loan Robert Maxwell? - Not him personally, but... - Loan the businesses? - I couldn't give you the details, but... it could be somebody investing in one of his companies that is buying new newspapers. Also enlarging the circle of papers that he had brought more and more influence to him on public opinion in many places. And that's something Israel needs quite often. - Would you say, then, that Robert Maxwell was part of an influence campaign? - Yeah. There's a name for that today. Perception makers. - Perception makers. - Yeah, perception maker. Because what you say is, OK, if I tell you the Russians are bad. they're responsible for A, B, C and D... I can create the perception, whether it's true or not. - 'Three people I interviewed say Maxwell did other types of work for Israel as well.' There've been claims that Robert Maxwell, as well as passing information, was a man who moved money. - Yeah, I would say that's correct. - And I'm not suggesting he was actually moving arms, but` - Arms as well. Anything! - So he could have been. - Absolutely. (TENSE MUSIC) - With that information, I ask Tom Bower for his take. - Maxwell had very, very close relations with Israel the last three, four years of his life. not because he was a Mossad agent, but because he felt very, very close to Israel, because of his own Orthodox Jewish background, and because he was a very good link between the Israelis and the Russians. You know, he didn't need to be a Mossad agent. He was a willing informant. I mean, there's nothing` nothing secret about it. The point is that Robert Maxwell was a media tycoon; he was not in the arms deals business. - But three sources tell me that Maxwell was involved in arms dealing. And they say that during the course of that, he met a young American ` Jeffrey Epstein. Syrian banker Amer Pacha was told by an arms dealer, who knew them both, that Epstein and Maxwell first met in the '80s, although Jeffrey denied to me that he ever met him. - I` I know that Jeffrey was selling arms. - How do you know that, Amer? - Because in 1992 and '93, I had very close ties to some members of the Saudi royal family, and they would always tell me, 'What do you think of this guy?' And my understanding that he was a very sophisticated banker and` - They would ask you about Jeffrey Epstein? - Yes. Yes. Jeffrey is a guy that everybody would feel terrified of him, but everybody wanted to be around him. He facilitated things very well. He was Mr Fix-It ` whether it's a political lobby, getting what some countries want. And I don't want to go into names, as I said to you, but he was a Mr Fix-It. He was discreet, sensitive, considerate-mannered. He was very careful, eloquent. He's very intelligent. He knows exactly if he's going into a trap. He always thinks that ` 'I'm going to be trapped somewhere.' So he traps you more than you trap him. That's his talent. He traps you. I was focused on his money. That's still crucial. Without the money, there would have been no alleged sex crimes, and Ghislaine Maxwell would not be facing the potential of life behind bars. In fact, how Jeffrey acquired his money is a question that gets to the heart of his criminal enterprise. Jeffrey Epstein, who is from Coney Island, he was a very good classical pianist, he was a very good mathematician, and yet he dropped out of college. He never finished his degree. Despite that, he wound up in 1974 as a maths teacher at Dalton ` one of the most elite New York private schools. And whilst he was there, he wound up giving private tutoring to a child of Ace Greenberg, who was then the chairman of Bear Stearns. And Ace Greenberg was so impressed with Jeffrey Epstein and his mathematical skills, that he asked him to come in and join the bank. I mean, that is not a normal route into an investment bank. In 2002, I knew that Jeffrey had left Bear Stearns in 1981 under murky circumstances, and I spoke to him then about his departure. - JEFFREY: Yeah, I don't deal with people who have narrow mindedness. I never had a run in with anybody, except people trying to say, 'You are a partner here.' I think I was the youngest partner ever there. - Jeffrey wanted me to speak to Jimmy Cayne, who was then the CEO of Bear Stearns. He wanted to tell me that Jeffrey Epstein was brilliant, and that he had been very upset when Jeffrey had decided to leave after only five years. So why did he leave? Here's what I recently had confirmed. In 1981, there was an investigation of possible illegal trading at Bear Stearns. Two sources say that Jeffrey was told to admit his own wrongdoing and resign. Neither he, nor anybody else, was charged in the case. After that, Jeffrey maintained a close relationship with the bank until it shut down. Jimmy Cayne wanted to tell me just how important Jeffrey Epstein was to the bank. A very important client ` that message was very clear. After leaving Bear Stearns in 1981, Jeffrey entered a new world ` one with very few people who are willing to talk. Someone who worked with Epstein for several years, Steve Hoffenberg, is one of the few. I went to see Steve Hoffenberg in jail in Devens, Massachusetts, in the fall of 2002. Hoffenberg was sentenced to 20 years in prison for committing the biggest Ponzi scheme in American history, prior to Bernie Madoff. And, in the judge's sentencing memorandum, the fact that Steve Hoffenberg had told so many lies to the government was a factor in giving him such a very long sentence. But many of the things Hoffenberg told me about Jeffrey Epstein in 2010 to have checked out, so I do take what he says seriously. I decided to do a follow-up interview with him. But, as a journalist, I've done my best to confirm everything that he says with another source. Hoffenberg tells me about another businessman Jeffrey was connected to at the time ` Douglas Leese. - Douglas Leese was a fascinating... individual. Very much like Robert Maxwell was. - Leese was a British defence contractor and an international Mr Fix-It. Sound familiar? - Jeffrey provided marketing presentations. He used the Douglas Leese network and expanded his abilities around the world to countries throughout the Middle East and other areas of the world. And Epstein loved the opportunity, and was very successful at it. - Arms deals means money moving around the world, sometimes invisibly. Amer Pacha told me that Epstein developed a reputation for money-laundering. What did you understand to be the main source of his money? - AMER: He was initiating very sophisticated financial instruments that is able to launder massive amounts of money. - So how does that exactly work? What kind of money is he washing? And how does` How does he do that? - Bonds, real estate, all kinds of financial instrument that he can put in place using any of his offshore holdings and offshore accounts. And then he was legitimising by actually real assets and real estate in New York, or Paris, or London. Assets that can be turned easily into liquid. - Jeffrey learnt how to move money offshore, and that's the skillset that he then starts to use with very wealthy, private individuals. - He wasn't an art connoisseur, but he dealt with very high-end art pieces. - So what do you` What do you mean by that? I don't understand that. - One way to laundry money is art. - Yes. - Everybody that knew Jeffrey knew that he bought at auctions, a lot of pieces, but everybody knew that Jeffrey was not 'into art'. - Another service that Jeffrey offered to private clients was recovering stolen monies for them. As he told me in 2002... - JEFFREY: Most people who have their money, if they are defrauded, prefer not to go to the police. They prefer to get their money back. The police usually don't get your money back. The person goes to jail, but you don't get your money. - The first scam that we know about, that he did on his own, there was a big criminal fraud case in the Southern District of New York. This group of Spanish families had lost a lot of money. Jeffrey worked with their attorney and actually found quite a large chunk of it. He flew into the Cayman Islands, picked up a suitcase of bearer bonds worth about $40 million. He then flew to Switzerland, deposited the bearer bonds in two Swiss banks. Jeffrey then conned the Spanish families into giving him power of attorney over these bearer bonds. The Spanish families never saw their money again. So that was the first example of what I call Jeffrey's 'three-pronged strategy' ` charm, control, con. You charm the people, you then take control of their money, and then you steal it. Steve Hoffenberg says he knew that Jeffrey had stolen money from other clients, but, nonetheless, he still hired him as a consultant for his company, Towers Financial. - Jeffrey could build Towers Financial substantially in funding ` selling securities and doing business illegally. - And in the years that followed, Jeffrey told Steve a great deal about his business dealings. Why do you think Jeffrey confided in you? I mean, was it because he had to brag? - He had to brag to overcome his insecurity. And he wanted to be important to me, and important to anybody in the room as an investment banker, and a serious, growing, powerful businessman on Wall Street. He was crazy. - As Jeffrey is rising in prominence in what is a relatively small world, it's not unlikely that he would have bumped into Robert Maxwell. That is what some people say they have direct knowledge did happen. Now, at the time, Robert Maxwell would have been very powerful; Jeffrey Epstein would have been the guy in the shadows. But there was a use for a guy in the shadows. - Jeffrey Epstein advised Robert Maxwell on how to reposition his debt in order to get out of the financial bind he was stuck in at that time. - Hoffenberg says both Jeffrey and Douglas Leese told him about intelligence work they did with Maxwell. And there's another source who says that Maxwell and Epstein worked together. One of the people who claims that there was this connexion is this man, Ari Ben-Menashe. Ben-Menashe was involved in arms dealing in the Middle East in the 1980s. A U.S. jury acquitted Ari Ben-Menashe around 1989 because the jurors believed that he was a member of Israeli military intelligence. (INTRIGUING MUSIC) The difficulty is that he has told certain stories to academics, to journalists, that can't be corroborated by anybody else and that have turned out to be fantasies. I've gone out of my way to try to corroborate whatever he said. Ben-Menashe tells me that Maxwell brought Jeffrey Epstein to Israel in the 1980s to meet with his contacts. - Maxwell took him there. - And you have firsthand knowledge of that? - Yes. - So why did Robert Maxwell bring Jeffrey Epstein to Israel? - He brought them there because he felt that this guy could help the Israelis. - Who did they meet with in Israel? - Robert Maxwell was... Ehud Barak's friend. Who was, at the time, Director of Military Intelligence. - Do you think Ehud Barak, who was obviously very busy fighting in the 1980s, would have known Robert Maxwell? - Oh, I have no doubt. Almost everybody in Israel knew Maxwell. - Ehud Barak would later become Prime Minister of Israel. He says now that he didn't meet Jeffrey until 2003. These are obviously huge allegations, and it's very difficult to prove. - Yeah, I know they're very difficult to prove, but there's one thing that is clear ` yes, he was working with the Israelis, for the Israelis, at some point. Yes, at some point. - Yes. - And he was introduced to the Israelis by Robert Maxwell. - Ben-Manashe claims that, like Maxwell, Epstein was brought on to conduct influence campaigns, but in a very different style. When you met Jeffrey Epstein through Robert Maxwell, you thought he was a thief and a con man, and didn't want to hire him for those reasons. Is that correct? - That's right. - But somebody did hire him. So who was Jeffrey working for? - The military intelligence, another group of people that hired him to go after people and try to blackmail them. - How was he going to blackmail them? - He taped people having sex with an underaged girls. He taped, he photographed, he did all that. And underage girls was his, uh... forte. one of Ben-Menashe's wild conspiracy theories? It's not clear. I couldn't get confirmation from other sources of a blackmail operation. If it's true, though, it raises some interesting questions. Did Jeffrey develop an interest in underage girls because of a blackmail campaign? Or did he come up with the blackmail idea because of his own interests? And how on earth did Ghislaine allegedly become involved? When did Jeffrey really meet Ghislaine Maxwell? That is a topic of peculiar confusion. There are many different stories, but we have four people who say they know that they met in the 1980s through her father, Robert Maxwell, who very much wanted them to become a couple. When, as far as you know, did Ghislaine and Jeffrey actually become romantically involved? - In the '80s. - So long before her father died? - Oh yeah. - Why did Robert Maxwell introduce Ghislaine to Jeffrey? - I think that Robert` Roberts wanted to have this guy as a son-in-law. (CHUCKLES) Funny enough, that I` he really` that's what I think. - Maxwell biographer Tom Bower doesn't believe any of it. - Jeffrey Epstein would have featured in some of Robert Maxwell's New York contacts, and I've got all those private papers, and he wasn't listed. Someone like Jeffrey Epstein would have been totally relevant. - Jeffrey's social life in the 1980s would have been the complete antithesis of Ghislaine's. As the daughter of one of the most prominent, powerful media moguls in England, Ghislaine would have been a very glittering figure in London. She would have been somebody who was very sought after at cocktail parties and dinners. - She moved with a very, very fast set after Oxford. Up all night, very expensive clubs, champagne, and so on. She certainly used to appear in the gossip columns. She made friends with Prince Andrew. - She was very, very skilled at moving into social circles and political circles. And you could say, 'Well, OK, that was because she had a certain amount of money.' No, she` she had something else. She had learned a lot from her father. - Everybody I've spoken to who was in Ghislaine's circle had a very clear idea of who Ghislaine wanted to be. She wanted to be, quote unquote, 'somebody'. She wanted to be somebody who mattered in the world in her own right. The great irony is she wanted to be like her father. There was talk of one serious boyfriend at the time. - She was linked to Gianfranco Cicogna, who was an Italian count, part of the Ciga hotel empire. I'm told she was very upset when that ended. I don't know. - (LAUGHS) 'My friend Christopher Mason first met Ghislaine during this time when she was visiting New York.' - One of the things I remember about Ghislaine was that she had short, spiky hair that was very kind of pixie-like. She was a kind of fireball of energy, a real livewire, that it felt exciting to be in her company. She told fantastically funny stories. She had quite a raucous sense of humour, lots of self-deprecating humour, and her conversation was sort of peppered with famous names of, you know, extraordinarily powerful people. - Did she talk about her father or her family in any meaningful way? - She kept referring to her father. I mean, he was kind of the big, swaggering publisher, and she seemed to be, you know, very much her father's daughter. - As Ghislaine travelled in these glittering circles, Jeffrey Epstein was socialising in a very different realm. Journalist Edward J. Epstein ` no relation ` met him at a party, in New York, in 1987. - Jeffrey would take people to dinner at the Regency, but it wasn't the Regency Hotel where the power meals were. It was a Regency delicatessen, and he'd order everyone a hot dog. - He told me he had lived in a penthouse. - He lived in the middle of the building, but the roof of the building was open to all the tenants, so he would tell people he lived in the penthouse, and he would order takeout food from a Chinese restaurant. And it was all pretty amusing. - I think you can see in the 1980s that Jeffrey was climbing. He was very gregarious, very social. He was definitely trying to build a network of people who are a lot richer and more important than he was, but he hadn't got there yet. You know, in the 1980s, he really didn't have much money to speak of. Jesse, I can't thank you enough for doing that. - Let me ask you, is this lighting OK for you? - Another journalist I know, Jesse Kornbluth, also met Jeffrey Epstein around the same time. - I met Jeffrey at a corporate party in 1986, and he was funny, and he was compelling. He dropped some magic words ` 'finance', 'bounty hunters'. - Who did he say he was bounty hunting for? - He said, 'I get money back 'for aggrieved parties from African dictators, 'and, on other days, I am hired by African dictators to protect their money.' - So you say to him, 'Let me watch you work.' And he says, 'Yes.' - Yeah. 'Come and meet me at Park Avenue South, 'and say 39th and 38th Street.' And we go up to a law firm and he presents himself to the receptionist, and she doesn't let him in. He tries to get in another way; he doesn't. And I realised he's doing process-serving. He's doing messenger work. - Did you ask him, 'How does this relate to bounty hunting?' - I didn't, because I saw` I made a judgement call that this guy was basically full of shit, and that there was no reason to pursue him. - This guy's business, he ran a sort of a little charm school. He charmed someone into giving him some money ` not millions, more like 50,000 or 100,000. He was a con man. And con men, you know, are very charming, and they know that there's very little risk, because what people want when they're conned is they want their money back. They don't want the embarrassment. They don't want to be involved in any legal processes. - In 1991, Jeffrey and Ghislaine's worlds intersected publicly when she moved to New York. - When Robert Maxwell bought the New York Daily News, he was immediately a huge personality in New York. So his daughter was able to exploit that remarkable passport to the celebrities, and used it. - I ran into Ghislaine early in 1991, and she said that she had just moved to New York, and her father is buying the Daily News, and she is making introductions for him. She seemed like the perfect person for that role; she was already staggeringly well-connected. - Jeffrey, meanwhile, was dating a string of young, mostly blonde, women. - Jeffrey liked attractive women, he liked talented women, he liked spending time with them, and they liked him. - You told me there was one woman ` a very beautiful woman he asked to go on vacation with him. - Yeah. She actually had an arrangement with Jeffrey where she had` there was no physical or sexual contact. But he` he told her that when he's meeting these masters of the universe, by having a beautiful woman with him, they assumed he must be important. He thought it added to his own stature, where he had very little else to add to his stature. It seemed to have succeeded. The women were very impressed with him, and he was generous towards them. - I think the other sort of really defining characteristic of Jeffrey's love life back then was that he was not monogamous. He was either targeting prominent rich women, or he was courting models ` very attractive women who he could mould to some degree. - (SPEAKS SWEDISH) - Jeffrey's longest relationship was with Eva Anderson, who dated him for 11 years. Eva Anderson was a former Miss Sweden. All the sources I've spoken to say that... as far as Jeffrey was capable of loving anybody other than himself, because it was quite apparent that he was an extreme narcissist, he really loved Eva Anderson. (TENSE MUSIC) Jeffrey and Eva stayed very close friends. He introduced her to a billionaire hedge fund owner named Glenn Dubin. They got married and Jeffrey was godfather to their eldest child. In 1991, it didn't seem that Ghislaine fit the type that Jeffrey favoured. She is the exact opposite of the kind of woman that Jeffrey typically liked in that she didn't need to be moulded by him at all. She was far more worldly. She had a much more extensive Rolodex than he did. But Ghislaine's world was about to change. Robert Maxwell extended his finances beyond breaking point. Robert Maxwell could not afford to buy the New York Daily News, but he was locked in this battle with Rupert Murdoch, and buying the New York Daily News would really cement Robert Maxwell as a global media mogul, not just somebody who operated in Britain. - There were the beginnings of rumours coming up in the press. I think he hoped, by his force of personality, to keep his business empire together. - The situation seemed untenable. And then, on November the 5th 1991, tragedy struck. - The millionaire newspaper publisher Robert Maxwell is dead. He disappeared overboard from his private yacht early this morning while cruising off the Canary Islands. - I want to thank all the many hundreds of people... who have sent messages of support... to us at this very, very sad time. - They recovered the body. It was a very quick inquest. And he was flown to Israel, and buried on the Mount of Olives as one of the righteous. (TENSE, DARK MUSIC) - It must be assumed that they want to pay tribute to an extraordinary man. - The death was ruled accidental, but in Britain, the speculation went on and on. - ARCHIVE: The mystery of Robert Maxwell and continues to dominate the front pages of London newspapers. - ARCHIVE: He committed suicide. He was rubbed out by assassins from a two-man submarine. - All the evidence shows that Maxwell suffered a heart attack. - Right. - They just didn't find any evidence of murder, let alone assault. They did find evidence that he had had a heart attack before he hit the water, because there was no sea water in his lungs. - Given the state of Maxwell's business, suicide was a strong consideration. And that seemed even more likely after it was revealed that he had tried to pay off his debts by stealing from his company's pension fund. - It quickly became clear that he'd been stealing from the pension fund. So people who'd long had suspicions about Robert which they couldn't prove felt that they were now justified, that he was a crook, that it was appalling that he'd let down all these workers. - The fraud could also explain why Maxwell would have been a target for murder. Books have been written claiming that Robert Maxwell was murdered by Israeli intelligence, and the claim is that he had gone from being an asset in Israeli intelligence to being a liability. - Maxwell had become very on edge. He built this massive empire he wasn't able to really control. - His demise, I guess, started when he started to need more money in order to fulfil his needs. He used the pension funds. He used it like a slush fund. Then when he needed it to be refilled, he was told 'No. 'No more.' - By the Israelis? - Right. 'No more because you're endangering the whole thing. No more.' And he started to make threats because he thought he was working with, you know, like any other company. He didn't understand ` you do not threaten the Mossad. - So do you think Robert Maxwell was killed by the Mossad? - I think so. Yeah. (CAMERA SHUTTERS CLICK) - Ghislaine told friends that she thought her father had been murdered. Other family members disagreed. - The family were very keen to prove that he died of a heart attack, because that's where they got the insurance money. Murder was unprovable, and suicide would've removed the chance of the payout. - In the end, however, the family was officially stripped of its money. - When one considered the amount he had defrauded, I think people felt, 'Why should they have anything?' - The optics of all this were horrific. Here is this man and his children who had lived high on the hog, with all the trappings of billionaires, and, meanwhile, you had all these people who'd actually toiled day in and day out for Robert Maxwell, who were suddenly left with no pensions. His two sons, Kevin and Ian, were charged with being their father's accomplice in this, and they had to then stand trial. - ARCHIVE: The two Maxwell brothers were guided out to a waiting police van. - After a week's-long trial, the jury acquitted both brothers. - If anyone had told me in the beginning of Kevin Maxwell's trial he was going to be acquitted, I would have bet huge odds in favour of the government, that they'd convict him. And yet he persuaded a jury of 12 men and women that he was innocent, because he drove his lawyers to destroy the prosecution case. - I'm naturally very pleased to have been cleared of all charges against me... - According to one report, Robert Maxwell hadn't been above using his favourite daughter, Ghislaine, as an unwitting courier to further his schemes. What was reported in Tom Bower's book about Robert Maxwell is that... I think it was 1990, Ghislaine had boarded the Concorde from London to New York, and that she had picked up an envelope, then flown back to London and given her father the envelope. According to Tom Bower, inside the envelope were shares of Berlitz stock. Robert Maxwell then went and sold those shares. The problem with that is he shouldn't have been able to sell them. Do you think she understood what she was doing? I mean, what she complicit? Or was she just doing something for her dad? - Well, she clearly knew what she was doing was important for the finances of the company. Whether she knew that her father was actually stealing the Berlitz shares is impossible to know, because she was never asked. I think that Ghislaine was living with a monster, a very brutal man, and he was a serial crook. She didn't know the difference between morality and immorality in the way of upbringing, in my view. That was the only way the Maxwells knew how to operate ` was by lying. (PENSIVE MUSIC) - There was anger and speculation about Ghislaine, who, within a month of her father dying, had left Britain, relocated to New York. And the speculation was that she knew there was Maxwell money there that the authorities couldn't get hold, and was living off it. - Christopher Mason visited Ghislaine in New York soon after her father's death. - It seemed like a fairly modest place for someone who was the daughter of an astonishingly wealthy man. And the message was that the money was gone. - It was revealed her father was a thief. Did she ever talk about that? - No. She didn't` She didn't speak of her father as dishonest. - ARCHIVE: Kevin Maxwell... 'She was quite passionate about the innocence of her brothers.' She was fiercely loyal to them. I remember her describing the funeral in Jerusalem, and it was very Ghislaine to hear her almost sort of bragging about the splendour of her father's funeral because he was so powerful, he was such a great man. And she was telling me about how she had spoken to various people, and I seem to remember Henry Kissinger was one of them, that she was saying, 'Let's just see. Let's just see what's happening in a year.' (INTRIGUING, MYSTERIOUS MUSIC) And I didn't know what the hell that meant. It just seemed to be that somehow she was going to figure out how to rise like a phoenix from these horrifying ashes. - Did Ghislaine know then that Jeffrey Epstein would be the person to help her rise again? And did she have any idea what she might be expected to do for him in return? (DARK, TENSE MUSIC)
Subjects
  • Documentary television programs--United States
  • Maxwell, Ghislaine, 1961--
  • Epstein, Jeffrey, 1953-2019
  • Child trafficking
  • Child sex offenders